2024-12-04

On November 29th, 2024, the Portuguese Government approved the rules for the deployment and maintenance of small-areas wireless access points through Decree-Law No. 97/2024. This decree establishes the legal framework for ensuring compliance with European Union ("EU") Regulation 2020/1070.

In a 5G environment, Small Area Wireless Access Points (SAWAPs) enable mobile devices to stay connected by either boosting the coverage of cellular networks or by offloading their data traffic to Wi-Fi networks, a process known as "Wi-Fi offloading. This allows to expand wireless networks and coverage without the need for additional infrastructure. The deployment of SAWAPs is crucial to achieve the objectives of the Radio Spectrum Policy Programme to ensure that all EU citizens have broadband access, both indoors and outdoors, at a speed of no less than 30 Mbps, as outlined in the Digital Agenda for Europe.

Electronic communications companies will now have the right to access public or private infrastructure suitable for installing wireless access points or connecting these points to a core network, such as lampposts, underground stations and traffic signs.

The installation and maintenance of SAWAPs areas will only be subject to subsequent notification, in line with the regime established by the Portuguese Electronic Communications Law for general authorizations, except in exceptional cases.

The main rules for the installation and maintenance of SAWAPs are:

  • Interested parties are now required to notify the Autoridade Nacional de Comunicações (ANACOM) through a designated platform within 10 days of the installation of network points. The notification must include the following details: (i) the geographical location of the network points, (ii) the installation and removal dates, (iii) the main technical characteristics, and (iv) the infrastructure used.
  • A register will be established to maintain up-to-date, geo-referenced data on public and private infrastructures suitable for installing small-areas wireless access points. ANACOM will be authorized to exempt certain types of infrastructure from inclusion in the register, subject to prior public consultation.
  • Since it is exempt from prior approval and fees, the consent of the infrastructure owner will serve the operator to not only install the access points but also to arrange the necessary services, such as energy supply.
  • However, the installation of small-areas wireless access points is subject to municipal authorization in the following cases:

a)     Monuments, groups of buildings, or sites classified as being of national, public, or municipal interest, along with their respective protection areas, as well as those undergoing classification, and cultural assets subject to protection under municipal master plans.

b)     b) Buildings or sites whose use is restricted for reasons of public safety, aimed at protecting people and property.

  • Municipal authorization can only be granted after a consultation with the relevant entities, which must provide their opinions on the approval of the small-areas wireless access points. This consultation process must be completed within a maximum of 20 working days.
  • The request for municipal authorization must be decided within a maximum of 40 working days.

Finally, no additional fees or charges can be applied for the deployment of small-areas wireless access points. Only in cases requiring municipal authorization will a one-time fee be applicable, payable at the time of application. This fee will depend on the administrative costs associated with processing the application, including the costs of obtaining opinions and overseeing the installation of the small-areas wireless access points.

 

2024-12-03

The Directive 2024/2831 of the European Parliament and of the Council (“the Directive”) on improving working conditions in platform work was published on November 11th, having the Member States, until December 2nd, 2026, to transpose the Directive into national law.

The Directive aims to improve working conditions in platform work and the protection of personal data, particularly by introducing measures to facilitate the determination of the correct employment status of persons performing platform work.

To accomplish its objective, the Member States must have appropriate procedures in place to determine the correct employment status of persons performing platform work, enabling the verification of the existence of an employment relationship, inter alia, through the legal presumption of an employment relationship in favor of persons performing platform work. This being similar to what already occurs in Portugal. Hence, the Directive foresees that, where facts indicating direction and control are found, there is a contractual relationship between the person performing platform work and the digital labor platform. In case the digital labor platform considers that an employment relationship does not exist, it will have the burden of proof regarding the non-existence of said relationship.

Article 12-A of the Portuguese Labor Code, approved in 2023, requires the existence of some facts evidencing an employment relationship for it to be presumed that such relationship actually exists: (i) the remuneration is set by the platform operator; (ii) the operator directs the way in which the provider operates and presents itself; (iii) the operator controls the activity provided, in particular through electronic means or algorithmic management; (iv) the operator restricts the autonomy of the provider with regard to the organization of the work, the possibility of accepting or refusing tasks, the use of subcontractors, the choice of clients or the provision of the activity to third parties via the platform; (v) the platform operator exercises employment powers over the provider, in particular by deactivating the account, and (vi) the equipment and work instruments used belong to the digital platform operator or are exploited by the latter through a leasing agreement.

There are already court decisions on the subject in Portugal.

The vast majority of decisions (around 11 to date) have considered that there is a hidden employment relationship within digital platforms, which must prevail even if the title of the contract says otherwise (e.g. Judgment of the Court of Appeal of Guimarães, 03/10/2024). There is also an opposing decision, which in a specific case did not recognize the existence of an employment contract. (Judgment of the Évora Court of Appeal, of 12/09/2024).

The new Directive has already been materially transposed into Portuguese law, so its approval in Portugal will no longer have a major impact in practical terms.

The development of the issue will continue to be carried out by the courts.

2024-12-03

On March 17, 2023, the European Commission introduced an added support plan to help economies affected by the war between Russia and Ukraine. One part of the plan is about encouraging investments in important industries that will help Europe move towards cleaner energy. These industries include the production of batteries, solar panels, wind turbines, heat pumps, and technology to capture carbon emissions.

In Portugal, the program "Investment in Strategic Sectors" created by Ministerial Order 306-A/2024/1 aims to support large-scale projects for a carbon-neutral economy in 2025, namely renewable energy production and storage. The program has a budget of one thousand million euros. Here are the key features of this incentive works:

  • It’s available to companies of any size in Portugal, including Azores and Madeira, but only for the production of the specific items mentioned above.
  • The amount of support companies can get depends on where they are located in Portugal and the specific rules of the program.
  • In most cases, the support will cover up to 15% of eligible costs, but there’s a limit of 150 million euros per company.
  • If the company is in the Lisbon Metropolitan Area or Algarve, the support can be higher — up to 20% of the eligible costs, with a 200 million euros limit.
  • If the company is in the North, Center, Alentejo, Azores, or Madeira, the support can cover up to 35% of the costs, with a limit of 350 million euros.
  • Eligible costs include things as purchasing machinery, equipment, and patents, but do not cover land, VAT, or financial expenses.

An online form is available to submit all applications to AICEP, the foreign investment Portuguese government agency. AICEP will review the application and recommend it to the program’s decision-making body, COMPETE 30, for a final decision on support.

2024-11-12

The Global Minimum Tax Regime approved by Law 41/2024 of 8 November implemented the Council Directive (EU) 2022/2523 of 14 December 2022  on ensuring a global minimum level of taxation for multinational enterprise groups and large-scale domestic groups in the Union.  

The aim of this Directive is to reinforce the efforts to avoid aggressive tax planning within the internal market by establishing a global minimum tax, mitigating the practice of shifting profit to jurisdictions with low or no taxation.

The 15% global minimum tax applies to entities that are part of multinational groups or large domestic groups, with consolidated income of €750 million or more in at least two of the previous four years.

Under this regime, the effective tax rate in each jurisdiction where the group operates will be compared with the minimum rate of 15%. After this comparison, it will be determined whether the group is required to pay a top-up tax, in accordance with the following rules:

  • Income Inclusion Rule (IIR).  The parent of a multinational enterprise group or of the large-scale domestic group (or the intermediate entity, if the parent is not subject to the IIR) will calculate and pay its allocable share of the top-up tax with respect to the low-taxed constituent entities of the group, or to itself.
  • Under-Taxed Profits Rule (UTPR). A constituent entity of a multinational enterprise group will be responsible for paying its allocable share of the top-up tax that has not been collected by the parent entities through the application of the IIR. The formula used for this purpose considers the proportion of employees and tangible assets in each jurisdiction, acting as a backstop to the IIR.
  • Qualified domestic minimum top-up tax (QMDTT): Portuguese companies subject to this regime will have the option to deduct a percentage of the value of tangible assets and employee salaries located in Portugal when calculating the taxable profits. This percentage will gradually decrease over the coming years, reaching 5% by 2033.

This regime is expected to affect large Portuguese groups with subsidiaries in other jurisdictions.

The new rules have entered into force on 9 November 2024, with retroactive effect as from 1 January 2024. However, the UTPR rule will only apply from 1 January 2025 onwards.

It should be noted that the Global Minimum Tax Regime establishes various transitional periods during which the additional tax will be reduced to zero.

2024-11-06

On November 4th, 2024, Decree-Law 85/2024 was published, implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/1807 into Portuguese law to establish a framework for the free flow of non-personal data within the European Union (EU).

A Regulation that establishes the free flow of non-personal data across the EU. Non-personal data includes information that does not directly identify individuals, such as aggregated and anonymised datasets, commonly used in large-scale data analysis.

This data type is gaining importance with the rapid expansion of the Internet of Things, Artificial Intelligence, autonomous systems, and 5G networks. The Regulation generally prohibits EU Member States from enforcing mandatory data localisation requirements for non-personal data, effectively removing rules or practices that require data to be stored and processed in specific geographic locations. Exceptions are allowed only for reasons of public security or national defence.

While Regulation (EU) 2018/1807 is mandatory and directly applicable within the Portuguese legal system, specific provisions require local implementing measures. These include appointing a competent authority as the local contact point, establishing mechanisms and procedures for notifications and communications with the European Commission, and defining the sanctioning framework.

The Decree- Law 85/2024 appoints the Agency for Administrative Modernization, I.P. (AMA, I.P.) as the local contact point, liaising with the single contact points of other Member States and the European Commission. AMA, I.P. is also tasked with managing and updating the single national information point.

The powers of AMA, I.P. include:

  • Providing and regularly updating detailed information on data localisation requirements applicable within the national territory and contributing data localisation information to a central information point.
  • Assisting the competent authorities of other Member States in accessing data in line with the cooperation procedures outlined in the Internal Market Information System (IMI).
  • Notifying the European Commission of any provisional data relocation measures implemented.
  • Preparing an impact assessment report with support from competent national authorities, who must gather and provide relevant data.

Existing data localisation requirements must be communicated to the European Commission, along with a justification based on public security grounds, in line with the principle of proportionality. The national authorities responsible for enforcing the data localisation requirements will carry out this communication.

Supervision is carried out by the Portuguese Food and Economic Safety Authority (ASAE), which may, if necessary, cooperate with other entities, particularly the Portuguese Data Protection Authority when personal data is at stake.

Regarding penalties, failure to provide information or providing false information and failing to grant access to data when requested by the supervisory authority constitutes a severe economic offence, punishable by a fine ranging from €1,700 to €24,000, depending on whether the company is micro, small, medium, or large. In turn, providing inaccurate or incomplete information constitutes a minor economic offence, punishable by a fine ranging from €250 to €12,000, depending on whether the company is micro, small, medium or large. At the same time, ASAE can impose ancillary sanctions.

The Decree-Law 85/2024 will enter into force on January 3rd, 2025.

To find out more about Regulation (EU) 2018/1807 on a framework for the free flow of non-personal data, learn more about our insights.

2024-11-04

On October 30th, 2024, the Portuguese Government approved a revised version of the National Energy and Climate Plan for 2030, known as "NECP 2030". This plan is Portugal's primary energy and climate policy instrument, outlining long-term goals and commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and promote the energy transition.

This is the first revision of the NECP 2030 since its publication in 2020, which has been subject to two phase public consultation. From March to April 2023, where 58% of the participants considered the goals ambitious, while 35% viewed them as not ambitious enough, highlighting the importance of establishing higher storage capacity. In the second phase, from July to September 2024, on the final proposal incorporating recommendations from the European Commission, 177 contributions were received, reflecting similar feedback to the previous phase.

The final version of the NECP 2030 establishes more ambitious targets than the version released for public consultation. It sets a goal of 93% (instead of 85%) of energy production from renewable sources by the end of 2030. The final version outlines a solar capacity target of 20.8 GW by 2030, representing an increase of 0.04 GW:

  • Centralized photovoltaic production capacity reaching 15.1 GW (instead of 14.9 GW)
  • Self-consumption solar production is set to reach 5.7 GW (instead of 5.5 GW).

Regarding wind energy, the NEPC maintains the estimates of 12,4 GW for installed capacity unchanged from the first version.

For green hydrogen production, the target has been reduced from 5.5 GW to 3 GW by 2030, establishing a less ambitious goal.

The target for installed battery storage capacity is set at 1 GW, despite a consensus that this amount is inadequate for the needs of the Portuguese electrical system. This limitation may lead to higher costs for consumers and could impact grid stability as increasing battery storage capacity is an effective way to address these challenges, according to the public consultation responses.

To know more on the PNEC: Portugal updates its 2030 Energy and Climate Plan.

2024-10-30

After the revocation of the Extraordinary Contribution on Local Lodging, effective retroactively from 31 December 2023, the latest changes to the legal framework governing local lodging establishments were published on 23 October 2024 and will come into effect on 1 November 2024.

Generally, these changes aim to grant greater decision-making power to municipalities regarding local lodging within their territories.

To this end, municipalities will be able to approve municipal regulations to govern this activity in their respective territories and may define containment areas (areas with restrictions on the establishment of new local lodgings) and healthy growth areas (a new definition referring to areas where special monitoring measures may apply to prevent undesirable effects of local lodgings overload on neighbourhoods). The municipal regulations may also include the appointment of a local lodging mediator, a new role primarily aimed at resolving local lodging disputes between the municipality and residents.

For containment areas, municipal regulations may establish, among other aspects, that new registries of local lodging establishments in buildings or units thereof that have been subject to residential lease agreements in the two years prior to registry cannot be authorized, as well as the conditions and limits applicable to new local lodging registries, particularly regarding duration and awarding rules. For new healthy growth areas, municipal regulations may stipulate, for example, the maintenance of a certain proportion or minimum number of residential building units where local lodging establishment cannot operate. Containment areas and healthy growth areas should be reassessed every three years.

The following changes are also noteworthy:

  • The approval of the commonhold owners’ assembly (assembleia de condomínio) is only required for the installation of hostels in units.
  • The deadline for opposing the registry request for the installation of a local lodging establishment extends to 60 days from the date of submission and to 90 days for requests to operate local lodgings in containment areas (previously 10 days as a rule and 20 days for hostels).
  • Violation of installation restrictions established by the municipality in containment and healthy growth areas and non-compliance with applicable legislation will now be grounds for opposing the registry request for the installation of a local lodging establishment.
  • Limitations to transfer of local lodging registries have been revoked. Nevertheless, it should be noted that the municipal regulation may impose restrictions on the transferability of new registries for certain local lodging establishments in containment areas (without affecting cases of succession, donation to spouse, partner, descendants or ascendants, and divorce, separation or partnership dissolution).
  • Three new conditions may now lead to the cancellation of the local lodging registry by the mayor: (i) lack of valid mandatory insurance, (ii) repeated and proven acts disrupting the normal use of the building, unless the dispute is settled, and (iii) in containment areas, if there are residential lease agreements in the two years prior to the relevant request, in violation of the municipal regulation.
  • It is clarified that local lodging establishments may operate in residential units and that commonhold property deeds or regulations may prohibit such operation. The commonhold owners’ assembly (assembleia de condomínio) may also prohibit such activity by resolution passed by a majority representing 2/3 of the buildings value (permilagem) but such limitation will apply only to subsequent local lodging registration requests.

In municipalities with more than 1,000 registered local accommodation establishments, the municipal assembly must decide, within a maximum of 12 months from the date the municipality reaches 1,000 registrations, whether to exercise the power to approve the above-mentioned regulation.

2024-10-25

In 2025, rents in Portugal may be updated by 2.16%.

According to Notice no. 23099/2024/2 from the National Institute of Statistics published on 18 October 2024, the annual rent update coefficient for various types of leases in 2025 will be 1.0216.

This coefficient reflects the variation in the Consumer Price Index, excluding housing, for the past 12 months and represents a decrease compared to 2024, which saw an increase of 6.94%.

Under Portuguese law, landlords and tenants can specify the terms of rent adjustment in the lease agreement. In the absence of such stipulation or by mutual agreement, the adjustment is made annually according to the applicable update coefficient.

The landlord should notify the tenant in writing, with a minimum of 30 days' notice, of the updated coefficient and the new resulting rent.

2024-10-14

The Portuguese Government presented the State Budget Proposal for 2025. It will be discussed and negotiated in the Parliament. The final vote on the State Budget proposal is scheduled for 29 November 2024.

In this newsletter, we summarise the main tax changes contemplated in this proposal.

Personal income tax

The main proposed changes to Personal Income Tax (PIT) are the following:

  • PIT brackets update. The PIT brackets will be updated according to the following table (pdf above).
  • Youth PIT. The Youth PIT rules, which partially exempt young people's employment income (dependent or self-employed), are amended as follows:

- Young people up to the age of 35 will now be eligible;

- The condition of completing a cycle of studies no longer applies;

- The PIT exemptions extend to the first 10 years of income, with the following limits:

  • 100% in the first year;
  • 75% from the second to the fourth years;
  • 50% from the fifth to the seventh years; and
  • 25% from the eighth to the tenth years.

- The exempted income cannot exceed 55 times the value of the Social Support Index (“SSI”) (i.e. €28.009,30).

Taxpayers who (i) benefit or have benefited from the non-habitual resident regime, (ii) benefit or have benefited from the tax incentive for scientific research and innovation, (iii) have opted for the taxation applicable to former residents or (iv) do have tax debts will not be eligible.

  • Meal allowance. The value of the meal allowance that is exempt from PIT, when given through meal vouchers, is increased from €9,60 to €10,20.
  • Withholding tax on supplementary work. Income from overtime work obtained in Portuguese territory by non-residents will be exempt from withholding tax in respect of the first 100 hours (instead of the 50 hours provided for in 2024), with the 25% withholding tax applying to the part that exceeds that limit or number of hours. It is also planned that withholding tax will apply to 50% (and not all) of the monthly remuneration for overtime work.
  • Withholding tax on self-employment income. The PIT withholding tax rate applicable to income from professional activities is reduced from 25% to 23%.
  • Autonomous taxation. The reference value of light vehicles acquisition cost for the calculation of the autonomous taxation will be increased, with the rate of 10% being applicable when the costs are less than €30,000 (instead of €20,000) and the 20% rate being applicable when the costs are higher. Vehicles powered exclusively by electricity are not subject to this taxation.
  • Advance payments. The total amount of advance payments due by self-employed persons will now be 65% (instead of 76.5%) of the legal basis.
  • Specific deductions from employment income and pensions. How the specific deductions from category A and H income are calculated has been changed from a fixed amount of €4,104 (updated annually according to the value of the income) to a fixed amount of €4,104 (updated annually according to the value of the income).
  • Minimum subsistence amount. The reference value for the minimum subsistence has been increased to the greater of €12,180 or 1.5 x 14 x SSI.

CIT

Regarding Corporate Income Tax (CIT), we highlight the following proposals:

  • Reduction of CIT rate. Reduction of the general CIT rate from 21% to 20% and, in the case of small and medium-sized companies and small and medium capitalization companies, from 17% to 16% on the first €50,000 of taxable income.
  • Health or sickness insurance costs.  Expenses associated with health or sickness insurance for employees and their families will be tax deductible at a rate of 120% when assessing the taxable net income.
    • Autonomous taxation. The rates of autonomous taxation for light passenger and cargo vehicles, as well as motorcycles, will be reduced by 0.5% and the cost limits will be increased by €10,000, as follows:

- For vehicles costing up to €37,500 (instead of €27,500) the rate will be 8% (instead of 8.5%);

- For vehicles costing between €37,500 and €45,000 (instead of €27,500 to €35,000) the rate is 25% (instead of 25.5%); and

- For vehicles costing €45,000 or more (instead of €35,000) the rate is 32% (instead of 32.5%).

It is also planned to exclude entertainment expenses related to shows from the scope of autonomous taxation.

VAT

In what concerns Value Added Tax (VAT), the following proposed changes stand out:

  • Extension, until December 31, 2025, of the VAT exemption (with the right to deduct the tax) applicable to transfers of certain goods, when normally used in the context of agricultural production activities, such as fertilizers and soil improvers.
  • Legislative authorization for the Government to amend in 2025 item 2.18 of List I annexed to the VAT Code to apply a reduced rate to the construction or rehabilitation works on residential properties, to be defined according to criteria established by members of the Government. Properties with a value exceeding the established limit will be excluded from the scope of this rate.

SPECIAL CONSUMPTION TAXES 

Rules on special consumption taxes will also be amended as follows:

PETROLEUM AND ENERGY PRODUCTS DUTY (ISP)

  • Certain oil and energy products used in facilities subject to an energy consumption rationalization agreement will now be taxed at 100% instead of 65%.

TOBACCO TAX

  • The total minimum reference tax to be applied to tobacco and in force each year will now correspond to the value of the national average tobacco tax.
  • The tax on cigarillos will now be 50% of the minimum tax on cigarettes instead of 100%.

VEHICLE TAX (ISV)

  • A rate of 25% will be applied to passenger cars registered in another EU Member State between 2015 and 2020 and with hybrid engines.
  • When the taxpayer disagrees with the provisional assessment issued by customs, the fee for requesting a recalculation is waived.

REAL ESTATE TRANSFER TAX

In what concerns the Real Estate Transfer Tax (“RETT”), the State Budget 2025 Proposal provides an update of the brackets for calculating RETT applicable to the transfer of urban buildings or autonomous fractions of urban buildings intended exclusively for residential use.

STAMP DUTY

Regarding stamp duty, we highlight the extension to 2025 of the exemption applicable to certain mortgage loan restructuring transactions, as well as transactions to temporarily fix the instalment and capitalise deferred amounts.

SPECIAL CONTRIBUTIONS

The 2025 State Budget Proposal extends the following special contributions to the year 2025:

  • Audiovisual contribution;
  • Banking sector contribution;
  • Banking sector solidarity surcharge;
  • Pharmaceutical industry contribution; and
  • Extraordinary contribution to suppliers of the National Health Service of medical devices.

TAX BENEFITS

The 2025 State Budget proposal includes the following proposed changes to the Tax Benefits Statute:

  • Incentives for salary increases. The costs related to salary increases for workers with a permanent employment agreement will be considered at 200% (instead of the 150% foreseen for 2024), provided that the following conditions are met:

- The increase in the average annual base salary per employee is at least 4.7% (instead of 5%); and

- An average increase of at least 4.7% in the annual base salary of employees who are paid the company's average annual salary or less.

For this purpose, the expenses related to (i) workers covered by a Collective Bargaining Agreement signed or updated less than three years ago and (ii) amounts spent by the employer on the worker by way of base salary and social security contributions will be considered. The maximum deduction from taxable income per employee is increased to five times (instead of four times) the guaranteed minimum monthly salary.

  • Incentives for the recapitalisation of companies. The 20% relief provided for capital contributions in cash to a company in which a shareholding is held, applied to the gross amount of profits or capital gains resulting from the sale of that shareholding, now covers any company and not only to companies with a loss of half their share capital. However, entities subject to supervision by the Bank of Portugal or the Insurance and Pension Funds Supervisory Authority, as well as branches in Portugal of credit institutions, other financial institutions or insurance companies, are excluded from this provision.
  • Incentives for the capitalization of companies. An amount corresponding to the 12-month Euribor rate plus a spread of 2% (instead of 1.5%) can be deducted when determining taxable net income. This measure will now apply to any company, instead of being restricted to small or medium-sized enterprises or small-medium capitalization companies. The relief will be increased by 50% in 2025.
  • PIT and social security exemption for performance rewards. If the employer complies, in 2025, with the conditions laid down for the application of the tax incentive for salary increase, there may be an exemption from PIT and social security contributions (SS) on the amounts paid in 2025 to employees as performance and productivity rewards, profit-sharing and balance-sheet bonuses, up to a limit of 6% of the annual base salary.
2024-10-08

The Portuguese Arbitration Court recently ruled in a case where the Portuguese Tax Authorities deemed a transaction abusive and applied the general anti-abuse rule (Case 498/2023-T).

Under the Portuguese general anti-abuse rule, set out in Article 38 of the General Tax Law, the Portuguese Tax Authorities have the power to tax transactions whenever they involve abusive practices, i.e., transactions carried out with the primary purpose of avoiding or reducing taxes through the misuse of legal forms.

This case concerned the transfer of shares of Company A to another entity, Company B, which had been recently incorporated. Company B had no operational activity and lacked the financial means to pay the purchase price for the shares. According to the Tax Authorities, Company B was created solely for the purpose of holding the shares of Company A.

The share purchase and sale agreement stipulated that the payment for the shares would be made once Company B received the profits from Company A that had been recorded prior to the share sale.

The transaction enabled Company B to benefit from the participation exemption on the profits distributed by Company A, while the sellers took advantage of a capital gains exemption on the purchase price received from Company B.

The Tax Authorities deemed the transaction abusive, as it was executed through artificial means and involved the misuse of legal forms with the intent to avoid taxes. Consequently, they applied the general anti-abuse rule and taxed the sellers on the profits they would have received had they not sold the shares in Company A to Company B.

The Arbitral Court ruled that there was no legal basis for applying the anti-abuse rule and annulled the tax assessment on the following grounds:

  • A company that holds shares in another company, even without operational activity, still conducts economic activity, albeit indirectly;
  • The transactions carried out by the shareholders had economic substance and were conducted following the law, meaning they could not be considered abusive; and
  • The outcome of the sellers’ decisions does not contradict tax law, as both the capital gains exemption and the participation exemption are provided for within the legal framework.

Finally, the Court concluded that choosing a more favourable tax route is simply an expression of private autonomy. If it adheres to the tax system, it cannot be regarded as an abusive practice.